You are taking 14 credit hours, dating a girl or a guy, and working hard 15-20 hours a week to stay alive. On top of it, church callings and extracurricular activities chip away at your time. Sound familiar? This situation is common to many students attending Brigham Young University. As a fellow student, I interact everyday with many who represent such a situation and possibly represent the situation in which you find yourself. During these conversations, there is the oft-asked question, “How are classes going?” To this comes a multitude of replies. Religion classes and their level of difficulty is a common topic. Difficult religion classes are defeating the aim of Brigham Young University’s religious education.
So what exactly is the purpose of Brigham Young University’s mandatory religious education? As a Church-owned school, Brigham Young University is among a handful of schools that require religious studies. Is this religious education the most important learning that actually takes place at this university? According to Brigham Young University’s Religious Education website, “The mission of Religious Education at Brigham Young University is to build the Kingdom of God by teaching and preserving the doctrine of the Gospel of Jesus Christ. We spread the light of the Restoration through classroom instruction, gospel scholarship, and outreach to the larger community.”
Religion classes are designed to implement and stimulate that growth among students, but is it really happening? No. From personal experience I know that I get so caught up in what is going to be on the next religion test and the information that I need to know to pass that I dismiss much of the Spirit-seeking that needs to be taking place. A specific example comes from the experience of a close friend. In his Teachings of the Living Prophets class, he wondered how the emphasis of the prophets’ teachings were so casually dismissed, and the focus was placed upon the lives of the prophets and how they almost died in their childhood, etc... What I am trying to say is that the focus has shifted too far from the personal application of the scriptures and the teachings of the prophets and seeking the Spirit to guide us.
Since religion is one of the most important aspects of a BYU education, religion classes cannot simply be ignored. The stringent grading policies are in place to ensure the desired diligence and learning on the part of the student. These classes are not early morning seminary. Brigham Young University cannot afford to have students falling asleep and having the wonderful opportunities offered here to be taken for granted. After all, the classes are not just a normal seminary class or even an institute class. There is a fear, undoubtedly, that comes from the religion department that students are just doing the minimum to get through a class and blow through their religion credits to get to their “more important studies”. A maximum of four credits per semester are accepted in an effort to curb such attitudes. This attitude does demonstrate a tragic misunderstanding on the part of the student. The grading is in place to guarantee the desired outcome and avoid negative approaches to religion classes.
But has the pendulum swung too far? Are religion classes becoming so ridiculously hard that students cannot learn in a Spirit-filled environment? Unfortunately, many students become discouraged after bombing a religion exam for which they honestly prepared. I am not saying religion classes should not be graded. On the contrary, grading the classes is important to measure dedication and commitment. I am also not saying that details of the prophets’ lives or scriptural insights should not be taught. I personally enjoy learning interesting facts and details about the scriptures and lives of the prophets. Too often, though, the need to memorize these extraneous facts overrides the need to search and ponder the scriptures. Tests are often overloaded with unessential questions in spiritual growth. The Honor Code established by Brigham Young University creates a unique learning environment. The university should trust the students to take charge of their learning and honor their commitment. This provides for one of life’s greatest learning opportunities. The Lord says, “…he that is compelled in all things, the same is a slothful and not a wise servant; wherefore… men should be anxiously engaged in a good cause, and do many things of their own free will…”
Personally, religion classes are an important part of my education. They provide a great opportunity to be taught from scholars and receive insights. I fully believe the religious education required is inspired of God for the blessing and profit of His children. With the focus on feeling the Spirit and seeking God’s inspiration in our lives, I believe three criteria need to be established as a basis for grading religion courses. First, class attendance must be a component. Second, reading the scriptures daily must be considered. This cannot just be reading to finish the reading but rather should be a timed amount of reading to maximize the influence of the Spirit in the students’ lives. Third, and last of all, application papers should be assigned to assess the ability of the student to follow the promptings of the Spirit.
Many are familiar with the website ratemyprofessor.com. I often check this website before registering for classes, particularly religion courses. I have had some tough professors in the past. With my desire to preserve my GPA, I have studied countless hours memorizing information for religion tests that I didn’t feel stimulated my spiritual growth. In my desire to find a professor that I feel better meets my desire to grow spiritually without the stressful memorization of random facts, ratemyprofessor.com has greatly helped. I must not be the only one, because those teachers’ classes fill up before lower classmen even get a chance to register. Conversely, difficult classes that seem to defeat the mission of Brigham Young University’s religious education always, without fail, are the last ones to fill up.
The religion teacher I have now is fabulous. He invites the Spirit into our class. He helps us understand the “why” side of religious education and then helps us understand “how” to get there. He constantly urges seeking the spirit, studying, and pondering the Spirit, in addition to requiring us to note our impressions and feelings in a study journal. Our quizzes consist of answering yes or no to questions regarding our reading, study journal writings, and attendance. The honor code governs our honesty and ultimately our desire to succeed and learn.
The Religious Education site later states, after its mission, that “The religion class should be an enjoyable and uplifting part of the Brigham Young University experience. Religion courses are expected to be…spiritually stimulating.” The Religion Department regularly needs to evaluate the results of religious education, making sure the teachings are on target with their aims. Whatever our current attitude toward religion classes, an understanding of how to have spiritually stimulating experiences should be our desired outcome from religious education.
here are some changes

I agree with you...my first Book of Mormon class was absolutely ridiculous. As opposed to learning necessary doctrine pertaining to my salvation, I learned petty little facts that who knows how they were even reputable. I really can't remember anything that stuck with me in that class. Other classes have really had a great impact, but those sought to help students learn by the spirit and not just for the grade.
ReplyDeleteI have loved all of my religion classes but I don't feel that I have gotten as much as I could have out of them spiritually as I should have because I was worried about the tests and assignments that I needed to do. If we have to be graded I believe that it should be done as a pass/fail grading, not true and critical class grading.
ReplyDeletegraded in religion classes are definitly defeating the purpose of the classes. Maybe they will change in in the future, but i doubt it. I still have a lot of religion classes and I guess i'll have to deal with it...
ReplyDeleteYou're right, Aaron. There's a reason Bro. Bott got the highest rating on ratemyprofessors.com out of the whole country. The religious department could learn a lot from him--he really does fulfill their mission statement. You can tell that he really cares, too--I still send him questions in emails and I last took a class from him before my mission. ...You know, maybe the difficult religious professors think we want to become seminary teachers or something.
ReplyDeleteI agree! i got a B on one of my family and marriage prep class... i guess that means i will have a B marriage? no jk but it is a little odd to push all of the spirituality out of a class by focusing on the hebrew root word for jot and tittle. Is that really what we should be focused on?
ReplyDeleteNo one could have said it better Aaron. There is so much to be learned from the scriptures that is worth our time, but there is also a lot that does not improve our spirituality. It would be great if all the religion professors would understand that.
ReplyDeleteI agree that a lot of the problems lie with the teachers. It is possible to grade in religion classes without hindering spiritual growth. Especially by application papers. That is where I think I have learned the most in my classes. Just seeing how the topic applies to my life.
ReplyDeleteI think it definitely ditracts from my spiritual learning to be graded so harshly in a religion class. Those tests and midterms can really stress me out, because I feel so pressured to do perfect on them since they pertain to the Gospel. I think the pass/fail grade would be a much better approach, and would definitely allow more room for spiritual growth instead of always having to worry and stress about religion exams.
ReplyDeleteHey I think I know that friend of yours that didn't like his teachings of the living prophets class. I agree with you 100%. No one in their right mind would try to grade someone on their spirituality. It is equally inefficient to make students memorize trivial facts. Best to go with the on-your-honor questions like, "did you read your scriptures fo the allotted time this past week?"
ReplyDeleteI agree with your point. I know that whenever I am in Book of Mormon, I do not try to feel the spirit because I am more focused on my next test and focused on trying to memorize every word the teacher says.
ReplyDeleteI have often felt the same way about the religion courses at BYU. There is nothing worse than bombing a religion test. It just makes you sick thinking about going to class and you don't have a desire to read or pay attention because there is no point; You're going to fail no matter what you do. I'm taking two religion classes right now, and one feels like a "busy work" class. There are a lot of quotes to memorize and the tests are so hard! The other class is great because there is a course packet that really helps you understand the scriptures.
ReplyDeleteI'm grateful to have the opportunity to learn more about religion while attending college, but some religion classes are ridiculously hard here at BYU. I have had classes that focused too much on grades and not so much on the spiritual aspect.
ReplyDeleteHey great job! I agree that some of the religion class are over the point. You presented your argument well.
ReplyDeleteI remember doing the group work on this. It is so true about what you bring up. I think that in an attempt to make Religion a class, they morph it into just another secular course.
ReplyDelete- Adam Arnett